Standards & Frameworks

    Carbon Footprint Product Declaration: ISO 14067 vs. EPD — When to Use Each

    A practitioner guide to carbon footprint of a product (CFP) declarations under ISO 14067 versus full EPDs under ISO 14025 and EN 15804 — covering methodology requirements, verification, and which sectors accept each format.

    9 min read

    Two Standards, One Goal: Credible Product-Level Climate Claims

    When a product sustainability team needs to communicate a product's environmental impact, two main credentialing routes exist: a Carbon Footprint of a Product (CFP) declaration conforming to ISO 14067, and a full Environmental Product Declaration (EPD) conforming to ISO 14025 (and EN 15804+A2 for construction products). Both are grounded in ISO 14040/14044 LCA methodology. Both require third-party verification for public claims. But they differ substantially in scope, cost, methodology requirements, and market acceptance.

    Choosing the wrong route — producing an ISO 14067 CFP when a downstream customer requires a full EPD, or investing in a full EPD when a CFP would satisfy the use case — costs organizations real time and money. This article gives practitioners the information to make that choice correctly.

    What Is a Carbon Footprint of a Product (CFP)?

    A CFP is a quantification of the greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and removals associated with a product system, expressed in CO2 equivalents, and calculated using a life cycle approach. The governing standard is ISO 14067:2018 (which replaced the 2013 version and the earlier PAS 2050).

    ISO 14067 operates within the ISO 14040/14044 framework and shares its core methodology: goal and scope definition, life cycle inventory (LCI), life cycle impact assessment (LCIA), and interpretation. The key constraint is scope: ISO 14067 addresses only climate change — it does not cover other environmental impact categories such as water use, land use, eutrophication, or acidification.

    A CFP declaration under ISO 14067 can cover: - Cradle-to-gate: Raw material extraction through factory gate (partial system boundary) - Cradle-to-gate with options: Gate plus specific downstream stages (e.g., use phase energy) - Cradle-to-grave: Full life cycle including end-of-life treatment

    The standard mandates that the system boundary choice be clearly stated and justified. Cradle-to-gate results cannot be compared directly with cradle-to-grave results, and the ISO 14067 communication requirements explicitly require this boundary to be disclosed.

    What Is an EPD?

    An Environmental Product Declaration (EPD) is a Type III environmental declaration under ISO 14025:2006 — a standardized, verified, and registered document communicating quantitative environmental information about a product based on LCA. Unlike a CFP, an EPD covers multiple environmental impact categories: climate change, ozone depletion, acidification, eutrophication, photochemical ozone creation, abiotic resource depletion, and additional indicators specified by the applicable Product Category Rule (PCR).

    For construction products, the relevant implementation standard is EN 15804+A2:2019+A2:2021, which specifies: - Mandatory life cycle modules (A1–A3 production, plus at minimum one end-of-life scenario) - The mandatory set of environmental and resource indicators (22+ in the A2 version) - Reference to EF 3.1 characterization factors - Requirements for data quality and reporting

    For other product sectors, PCR-based EPDs are issued under program operators such as EPD International, IBU, SINTEF, or EPEA. Each PCR defines the specific methodology, scope, and indicator set for the product category.

    Head-to-Head: ISO 14067 CFP vs. EPD

    DimensionISO 14067 CFPFull EPD (ISO 14025 / EN 15804+A2)
    StandardISO 14067:2018ISO 14025:2006 + PCR + (EN 15804+A2 for construction)
    Impact categories coveredGHG / climate change only10–22+ categories depending on PCR
    System boundary optionsCradle-to-gate, gate-to-grave, cradle-to-gravePCR-mandated (often A1–A5 + end-of-life minimum)
    Biogenic carbonMandatory treatment per Annex DPer PCR (EN 15804+A2 requires separate reporting)
    Land use change (LUC)Required if significantPCR-dependent
    Program operator requiredNo (self-declared possible, but verification recommended)Yes — EPDs registered with recognized PO
    Third-party verificationRequired for public comparative assertionsMandatory for publication
    Registration / public databaseNot requiredRequired for publication (PO database)
    CostLower (single impact category)Higher (full indicator set, PCR fee, PO registration)
    Typical production time4–8 weeks (experienced practitioner)8–20 weeks (depending on data availability and PCR complexity)
    Market acceptanceFashion, food, consumer goods, electronicsConstruction, public procurement, regulated markets

    ISO 14067 Methodology Requirements in Detail

    Practitioners moving from generic carbon accounting to ISO 14067 must navigate several methodology choices that are more rigorous than typical Scope 3 inventory approaches.

    System Boundary Definition

    ISO 14067 requires explicit justification of the system boundary relative to the product's full life cycle. Exclusions must be documented and shown to be below the cut-off criteria specified in the goal and scope section. The standard does not specify a universal cut-off threshold — the study must justify whatever threshold is applied. A common practice is to adopt the EN 15804 cut-off criteria (1% mass, energy, or environmental relevance per excluded flow; maximum 5% aggregate) and document the rationale.

    Biogenic Carbon Treatment

    ISO 14067 Annex D (normative for cradle-to-grave studies) requires explicit treatment of biogenic carbon — CO2 stored in biological materials (wood, cotton, starch-based packaging). The standard allows two approaches:

    1. Include biogenic carbon in the inventory: Count biogenic CO2 uptake during growth as a removal and biogenic CO2 release at end-of-life as an emission, netting to near-zero for sustainably sourced materials over the full life cycle.
    2. Exclude biogenic carbon: Report only fossil GHG emissions, treating biogenic flows as neutral by assumption.

    EN 15804+A2 requires separate reporting of biogenic carbon flows (not netting), which creates a methodological tension when comparing ISO 14067 results to EPD results for products with significant biogenic content (timber, paper, bio-based plastics).

    Land Use Change (LUC)

    For products with agricultural or forestry inputs, ISO 14067 requires assessment of LUC emissions — the release of sequestered carbon when land is converted from forest or grassland to cropland. This is methodologically complex: LUC emissions depend on the origin of the input, the land conversion history, and the time horizon used. The most defensible approach uses primary data on input origin combined with country or region-specific LUC emission factors from recognized sources (IPCC Tier 1 defaults, or ecoinvent LUC factors).

    Neglecting LUC for products with significant agricultural content (leather, cotton, soy-derived inputs) will typically be flagged by a technically rigorous verifier.

    Allocation

    When a production process produces multiple co-products, the GHG burden must be allocated between them. ISO 14067 follows the ISO 14044 hierarchy: expand system boundary to avoid allocation first; if not possible, allocate based on physical causality; if not possible, allocate by economic value. The allocation approach must be documented and the sensitivity of results to the choice assessed.

    How to Structure a CFP Declaration Document

    A compliant ISO 14067 CFP report for a public claim should contain:

    1. Goal and scope: Product description, functional unit, declared unit, system boundary (with diagram), cut-off criteria, data quality requirements, allocation rules, impact assessment method (GWP100 from IPCC AR6 or AR5 — specify the AR version), and intended audience.
    2. Life cycle inventory: Summary of inputs and outputs by life cycle stage. Foreground data sources and collection methods. Background database reference (ecoinvent version, system model).
    3. Life cycle impact assessment: GWP result disaggregated by life cycle stage (A1 materials, A2 transport, A3 manufacturing, A4 distribution, A5 installation if applicable, B use phase, C end-of-life, D beyond system boundary). Biogenic carbon reported separately if Annex D applies.
    4. Interpretation: Hotspot analysis, sensitivity analysis for key parameters, limitations and uncertainties.
    5. Critical review statement: If the declaration will be used for public comparative assertions, ISO 14067 requires an external critical review by a qualified panel. The review statement (or verifier's report for a simpler verification) must be included.
    6. Communication summary: A consumer-facing or B2B summary conforming to ISO 14067 communication requirements — including mandatory disclosures about system boundary, verification status, and date of study.

    Third-Party Verification Requirements

    ISO 14067 requires third-party verification for any CFP used in a public comparative assertion — a claim that your product has a lower carbon footprint than a competitor's. For internal use or non-comparative public claims, verification is strongly recommended but technically not mandated by the standard.

    In practice, most organizations seeking to use CFP results in procurement, marketing, or regulatory contexts pursue verification regardless of the comparative assertion question, because unverified CFP claims are increasingly viewed with skepticism and may trigger scrutiny under the Green Claims Directive in EU markets.

    Verifiers for ISO 14067 studies should have: - Competence in LCA methodology (ISO 14040/14044) - Familiarity with ISO 14067 requirements - Independence from the commissioning organization - Relevant product sector knowledge

    For full EPDs, verification is mandatory and must be performed by a verifier recognized by the program operator. IBU maintains a list of qualified verifiers for IBU-registered EPDs. EPD International similarly maintains an approved verifier list.

    Who Accepts CFP Declarations vs. Requiring Full EPDs

    Market acceptance varies substantially by sector and by the specific procurement or regulatory requirement.

    Sectors where ISO 14067 CFP declarations are commonly accepted:**

    • Fashion and apparel: The Higg Materials Sustainability Index and similar tools accept CFP data. Brands collecting supplier material footprints typically accept ISO 14067 data.
    • Food and beverage: The PACT (Partnership for Carbon Transparency) framework and WBCSD guidance on product carbon footprints are ISO 14067 aligned. Retailer supplier programs (Walmart Project Gigaton, Tesco, etc.) accept PCF data.
    • Consumer electronics: Many scope 3 supplier data requests accept ISO 14067 CFP, especially for component-level contributions.
    • Chemicals: BASF, Dow, and similar suppliers have published ISO 14067 CFPs for industrial chemical products.

    Sectors where full EPDs are required or strongly preferred:**

    • Construction and building products: EN 15804+A2 EPDs are required for building-level LCA tools (One Click LCA, Tally), for French RE2020 FDES declarations, for DGNB, LEED, BREEAM EPD credits, and increasingly for public procurement in Nordic countries.
    • Public procurement (EU): Most GPP criteria for product categories reference EPDs specifically, not CFP declarations.
    • EPD program operator submission: By definition, only EPDs (ISO 14025 + PCR) can be registered with program operators and appear in public EPD databases.
    • Green building certifications: LEED v4 and v4.1, BREEAM New Construction, and DGNB all require EPDs specifically, not CFPs.

    The bottom line: If your customer base is in construction, public procurement, or green building certification markets, invest in full EPDs. If you are providing component materials to manufacturing supply chains, apparel, or food sectors, ISO 14067 CFPs are frequently sufficient and substantially faster to produce.

    When to Upgrade from CFP to Full EPD

    Several signals indicate it is time to move from an ISO 14067 CFP to a full EPD:

    • A key customer or procurement requirement explicitly requests an EPD registered with a recognized program operator
    • You are entering a building sector market (residential, commercial, infrastructure)
    • You are seeking points under LEED, BREEAM, or DGNB for EPD credits
    • A proposed regulatory requirement for your product category references EPDs specifically
    • You want to appear in ECO Platform or international EPD databases for discoverability
    • Your CFP study already covers all life cycle stages (cradle-to-grave) and adding additional impact categories is incremental work

    The incremental effort to convert a rigorous ISO 14067 study to a full EPD is lower than starting from scratch, provided the underlying LCA model was built to EPD-level standards from the start.

    How ClimatePoint Supports Both Approaches

    ClimatePoint's LCA platform is built on ISO 14040/14044 methodology and supports both CFP and full EPD outputs from the same underlying model:

    • CFP workflow: Build your LCI model, select GWP-only reporting, and generate an ISO 14067-conformant CFP report with stage-disaggregated results and biogenic carbon treatment.
    • EPD workflow: Extend the same model to the full EN 15804+A2 indicator set (licensed ecoinvent indicators, included on paid accounts) and match it to a PCR. Our analysts then prepare the LCA project report and a draft EPD for your independent verifier; the programme operator registers and publishes the verified EPD.
    • Shared data model: Foreground data entered for a CFP study is reused if you later expand to a full EPD, avoiding duplicate data entry.
    • PCR matching: ClimatePoint matches your product to a PCR from its PCR index and pre-selects the boundary and module rules for it. The index points to PCRs rather than holding every PCR text, so the analyst checks the current PCR from the programme operator.

    Whether you are producing your first ISO 14067 declaration or managing a portfolio of EPDs across multiple program operators, ClimatePoint handles the LCA methodology so your team can focus on the product data. Book a call at climatepoint.com to discuss your specific product category, target markets, and verification timeline, or start a free trial to see the platform firsthand.